Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (Feb 2018)
Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guyPV and get this in real time, by going to PremoSocial. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments or Enduring Intellectual Properties. Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.
- Link to my appearance on TD Ameritrade Network [on Monday]:
- It looks like I will be able to do most of my CPI tweet storm after all. I will be on Bloomberg live at 8:30ET with @adsteel and @DavidWestin, but I will be on the phone and will post my tweets immediately thereafter.
- Going in, we’re facing roughly a 0.21-0.22% consensus on core CPI. I think to get an adverse reaction from equities you need to keep y/y from declining to 1.7%, which means you need core CPI to be near the year-ago comp, which means something that rounds to 0.3%.
- Anything that rounds DOWN to 0.3% will be ugly. Again I’m talking core here.
- It’s important to remember that this is the hardest remaining comp we have in CPI for a long time. In fact, Jan 2017 m/m was higher than any other core print of 2017. The next 6 months are only 1.1% annualized.
- This is why we can talk about the ‘bad optics’. Core CPI will appear to be rapidly accelerating over the next half-year unless we get some weird one-offs like we did last year.
- This month I will be especially focused on Used Cars and Trucks, which is subject to a change in BLS procedure this month. Big difference of opinion out there about whether it’s an add or subtract.
- I believe it will be an add, because the price level is what BLS surveys and this has been very far below what private surveys have shown. Catching up to do unless the BLS just ignores that prices are higher than they thought.
- But a tremendous amount of noise around any element of the data so it could be anywhere of course!
- Have to go now and prep for Bloomberg call. Will be back several minutes after CPI for recap. Thanks for subscribing, everyone.
- oh my…0.349% on core…1.846% y/y…and this was supposed to be the hard comp.
- Supposedly the seasonals were going to dampen this figure. Whoops.
- Remember this is a January number but…it’s hard to ignore. Accelerating major categories: Food/Bev, Apparel, Medical Care, Other.
- Housing decelerated but that was mostly Lodging Away from Home, -2% for the month. AirBnB making a comeback?!? Primary Rents accelerated to 3.73% from 3.68% y/y and OER to 3.20 from 3.17%. This is on our model.
- Here’s last 12 m/m core CPIs. Notice a trend?
- CPI-used cars and trucks…was 0.32% m/m. Sorry, people who thought that it would be down. y/y though it’s still a drag at -0.61%. But last month that was -0.99%.
- In Medical Care, Pharma decelerated to 2.39% vs 2.77%. But Doctor’s Services -1.51% vs -1.77% y/y last; Hospital Services 6.04% vs 5.09%.
- That matters more than you think, because more care is being funneled through hospitals every day.
- CPI for medical care…bottoming?
- CPI pharma
- Now, whilst Used cars and trucks accelerated, New Vehicles decelerated to -1.24% vs -0.53% y/y last month. And New Vehicles have almost twice the weight of used vehicles. So cars, actually, were a net drag. Just not the place that pointy-head economists said it would be.
- I wouldn’t get too overenthused about apparel. Yes, it had a big jump. And with a weaker dollar and some protectionism I’d expect to see this going up. Just…lot of wood to chop.
- Sorry I am jumping around a bit. Back to hospital services. Near longer-term high pace, but really need to see it break higher. This is an important part of core services.
- Here’s CPI-Used Cars vs the Manheim survey. Rate-of-change. Looks like it’s catching up. But…
- Here (again) is the index level (normalized) of CPI vs Manheim. This month’s move doesn’t do much. EVEN IF THE HARVEY JUMP IN MANHEIM GOES AWAY, BLS is still way below where it should be. This is a source of positive variance going forward.
- Here is the distribution of price changes. As expected the weight in the left tail is starting to decline, which will cause core to converge with median eventually (or anyway, get close).
- OER accelerated slightly, but as I mentioned this is what our model expects. Not to anthropomorphize a model. The real question is which of our submodels – which agree at this level but diverge – ends up being ‘correct’.
- So here’s the ‘four pieces’ look. What it shows, frighteningly, is that nothing unusual is happening. As a reminder to people seeing this 1st time…this breakdown of CPI has four roughly-equal pieces.
- Food and Energy
- Now the core pieces. Core Goods. With dollar weakness this will eventually go mildly positive. But this happens with a lag and hasn’t happened yet. Maybe Apparel is first shot?
- Core Services less Rent of Shelter. If Medical Care is bottoming, this is an upside risk. I doubt there’s much downside risk at this point.
- And Rent of Shelter. It’s decelerated, but home prices are still rising and I don’t think this is going to drop out of the sky. Net result: hard to see where disinflation would come from.
- This is where I usually conclude by forecasting Median CPI. But median category looks like a subcomponent of OER, which the Cleveland Fed separately computes a seasonal adj for. However, looks to me like Median won’t be anywhere close to core. Probably around 0.2%.
- Looking forward, remember: the EASY core comps are ahead. Feb 2017 was +0.17%, March -0.07, April +0.09%, May +0.08%. June and July 0.14%. Not until Aug do we have another 0.2% comp. This means core CPI is going to be rising from the current 1.85%.
- …and that in turn is going to scare investors, and the Fed (which usually follows the bond market) might overreact for all their brave talk currently. Today’s data certainly created a WTF moment at Constitution and 20th St. NW
- That’s a wrap for now people. It was a fun one. Thanks for tuning in! Thanks for signing up!
The big takeaway from this month was that this was supposed to be the difficult comp for year/year CPI. With all of the sturm und drang about inflation over the last couple of weeks, this was set up to be a whipsaw when the January data turned out to show a decline in year/year core CPI. Going into the data, I would have preferred the long side of equities (for a trade) because it seemed like the talk around this CPI was overdone.
But instead we got the highest m/m core CPI in 12 years, and it was very close to printing 0.4% with rounding. That would have been heart-stopping.
The stock market seems at this hour to have fallen in love with the idea that this was all due to “weird jump in Apparel.” But Apparel is only 3% of CPI and 4% or so of Core. So a 1.5% miss in Apparel would only add 0.06% to core CPI. And core CPI missed by more than twice that. Moreover, the jump in Apparel is just reversing some curious recent weakness in the series, so arguably it’s an unwind of a one-off, not a new one-off. Year/year, Apparel is still deflating at -0.62%/year even with this month’s jump. That’s steeper deflation, actually, than the four-year average! With the dollar weakening, I would expect Apparel to be adding, not subtracting, from inflation over the balance of this year. But, with such a small weight…who cares?
I agree that one should not exaggerate the importance of any one month’s data, for any data series (including Average Hourly Earnings, which seems very likely to reverse some next month). But the next six months are going to see core inflation continue to rise, optically. If we get “only” 0.2% prints for each of the next six months, then July core CPI will be around 2.5% y/y. At that point, people will be extrapolating crazy numbers. But for now, we still have all of the ugly optics to look forward to.
This is a bad figure. There are no two ways about it.
What the hell did the equity markets see that the bond market didn’t?